Why the Eagles Shouldn’t Rush to Label the Carson Wentz Trade a Massive Success

The Eagles trade for Carson Wentz was a “massive success” according to the team and their fans. But there is no guarantee he will return to his MVP form, so it makes sense that Philadelphia would want to move on from him in case things don’t work out.

The “carson wentz news” is a topic that has been in the news recently. The Eagles traded for Carson Wentz, and many people are saying it was a success. However, there are some who believe this trade could be a failure.

Following the Indianapolis Colts’ Week 15 victory over the New England Patriots, quarterback Carson Wentz met the 75 percent snap barrier necessary for Indy’s first-round choice to be transferred to the Philadelphia Eagles. The two parties reached an agreement on a trade this summer, with the catch being that Wentz had to play a set proportion of plays in exchange for a second-round selection from the Colts being converted to a first-round pick. Wentz has been healthy throughout the season, which means he reached the milestone three weeks before the season concluded.

On paper, this seems to be a huge win for the Eagles. Their overall number of first-round picks in 2022 rises to three, positioning them for a lucrative offseason.

Not so fast, my friend.

The Eagles’ quarterback, Carson Wentz, is doing better than they would like to think.

The Eagles have acquired the Colts’ 2022 first-round selection as part of the Carson Wentz deal after yesterday night’s game. That translates to three first-round picks for Philadelphia, who are presently ranked 10, 11, and 23 overall.

December 19, 2021 — Matt Miller (@nfldraftscout)

For most Eagles fans and writers, Week 15 was remembered for Wentz having perhaps his worst game in the NFL. Against a suffocating Patriots defense, he only threw for 57 yards, making it easy for Philadelphians to point and laugh at Indianapolis for giving up their first-round pick for him.

After zooming out and looking over the whole 2022 season, it becomes clear that Wentz has been one of the better-performing quarterbacks in the league this season. While he wasn’t the reason the Colts defeated the Patriots this past weekend, his consistent play week after week is a significant reason why Indy has weathered the storm after a sluggish start and now sits in the top wild-card slot in the AFC.

Wentz is presently ranked 10th in throwing touchdowns (23), third in interception rate (1.4%), and sixth in quarterback rating in the NFL (58.2).

That’s right, you read it accurately. Wentz has the sixth-best QBR in the league after 15 weeks of NFL play. Kyler Murray, Russell Wilson, Lamar Jackson, Joe Burrow, Josh Allen, and Dak Prescott all had worse ratings than him.

Despite what some media outlets may have said after his poor performance against the Patriots, Wentz has shown to be precisely what the Colts were looking for. He’s a good quarterback who throws a lot of touchdown passes and few interceptions.

The Eagles are still looking for a quarterback.

The Eagles fall 13-7 and can only blame themselves. A devastating offensive gameplan resulted in four turnovers, including three interceptions by Jalen Hurts. Jalen Reagor still had two passes in his hands in the dying seconds to win the game. Ugly.

November 28, 2021 — Bo Wulf (@Bo Wulf)

When the Eagles originally traded Wentz this past summer, there was a palpable feeling of relief among the fans. People were relieved to be free of Wentz’s large contract and delighted to see a fresh face (Jalen Hurts) in the starting lineup.

In the big scheme of things, the Eagles have quietly crept into a borderline playoff berth owing to an underperforming NFC, but they remain in a troubling position: quarterback purgatory.

Hurts is a world-class runner, there’s no doubt about it. However, his throwing numbers this season have been on pace with some of the league’s worst quarterbacks. Hurts has a 25th-place finish in throwing touchdowns, a 17th-place interception rate, and a 19th-place QBR. Although his speed adds a good aspect to the argument, he has been a poor passer.

Sure, if the Eagles decide to keep Hurts, he may continue to improve year after year. Patience has paid off for clubs like the Dallas Cowboys (Dak Prescott) and the Seattle Seahawks (Russell Wilson). We’ve seen this, however, lock teams into multi-year tank tasks (New York Jets with Sam Darnold, New York Giants with Daniel Jones).

What’s next for Philly?

Former Eagles QB Carson Wentz. Andy Lyons/Getty Images/Carson Wentz

The Colts have their quarterback, whether you believe he’s a top-10 QB or not. They obtained a franchise quarterback without having to go through the ups and downs of developing a struggling rookie, and they look to be on track for several playoff berths in the coming years.

The Eagles, on the other hand, had no firm plans in place for the post. They may continue to rock with Hurts for another year or two, but they risk squandering the last years of some of their veterans while the assessment process continues. Alternatively, they could trade multiple first-round selections for Russell Wilson, who now has a lower QBR than the man they recently booted out of town in Indianapolis.

Recovering a first-round selection for Wentz after his worst season in the NFL is a major victory on paper. However, a deeper examination reveals that it is significantly more sophisticated than that. The most difficult task in the NFL is finding a starting-caliber quarterback. The Indianapolis Colts have one. The Eagles, on the other hand, do not.

Who is the true victor?

Pro Football Reference provided all stats.

RELATED: Three Eagles Players Deserving of Pro Bowl Selection

Watch This Video-

Related Tags

  • carson wentz instagram
  • philadelphia eagles mock draft
  • carson wentz college stats
You May Also Like